this is the story of two cakes. one a beautiful cake and the other, a shipwreck. or train wreck, take your pick. either name will work.
as i have mentioned before, i work in a demonstration garden with my fellow master gardeners. it is my responsibility as the project chair to round up the volunteers and maintain the garden. to do this, i have resorted to bribery; it works out so much better than whining and begging…since i go out to the garden every sunday morning, i have made it a habit to take a freshly baked cake with me. sounds easy but it is a challenge to come up with a different cake each week.
the result is that every week, i create a new recipe. sometimes, it is as simple as substituting an ingredient or two in an already successful recipe. other weeks, it can be complicated as i attempt a new formula all together. most of the time, the cake works out and i am able to make minor adjustments to use the next time i bake the cake. other times, not so much. this last time, really, really not so good. and by not so good, i mean the cake was self destructing from the moment i took it out of the oven.
don’t you love the ski slope effect? trust me, it went completely down hill from here…
as i stood there looking at my sad cake, i watched in horror as more and more of the sides of the cake just fell off and littered the tray. so sad, so embarrassing. how would i fix this? there wasn’t any time to bake another cake, i would just have to bring it out to the garden and hope for the best. the best laugh that is. shirley quickly dubbed it a total shipwreck. and honestly, it was-no harm, no foul, just lots of giggles. she and lynn were astonished that i could have baked this. so as you see, even a pastry chef is capable of a shipwreck every now and then. the mistake here, i tried to temper the acid level of fresh pineapple by adding a little baking soda to the recipe. guess what, the cake did not need any tempering.
so this week, when i set out to bake a cake for my gardening friends, i had a new challenge; no eggs. we have a couple of new volunteers that both follow a mostly vegan diet and the eggs needed to go. luckily, they were both okay with a small amount of butter but definitely not the eggs. and luckier still, i happened to have a package of ener-g egg replacer in the pantry and a supply of coconut milk and coconut oil. i also had the determination of a baker scorned; i simply was not going to be pushed around by a cake. no, i was going to win this thing, we were going to eat pina colada cake and it was going to be a good cake. no ifs, ands or buts. just a really good cake!
recipe notes: to get a nice pineapple flavor, use fresh, ripe pineapple. peel, core and cut enough of it into 1″ cubes to make 2 cups. place the pineapple in a food processor and pulse to produce tidbits. do not let the machine run for more than 5 or 10 seconds at a time or you will quickly make puree. put the pineapple tidbits into a mesh strainer and press out as much of the juice as you can. reserve the juice for the syrup that is poured over the warm cake. 2 cups of chunks should yield 1 cup of tidbits and 1/2 cup of juice which is what you will need for the cake.
for the liquid in the recipe, i have used coconut milk. to get the best texture without it being gummy or overly moist, use a light coconut milk or an unsweetened coconut milk beverage. these will add moisture without excess fat that can make the cake greasy and heavy.
for the vegans, use all coconut oil(2/3 cup) and ener-g egg replacer(4 1/2 teaspoons mix to 6 tablespoons of warm water). for the not so vegan, you can do as i did and use half unsalted butter(6 tablespoons) and half coconut oil(1/3 cup) with the egg replacer. and for those of you throwing caution to the wind, you can also just use 3 large eggs, and all butter but you will have to use coconut milk to be able to call it pina colada!
if you have never used ener-g egg replacer, it is easy! follow the instructions on the box and use as you would real eggs. place the powder in a mixing bowl, whisk in warm water and let it sit while you start mixing the recipe.